Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Dailuaine 12 Year (2010), Thompson Brothers

Dailuaine 12 Year (2010), Thompson Brothers

Whisky: Dailuaine 12 Year (2010), Thompson Brothers

Country/Region: Scotland/Speyside

ABV: 55.4%

Cask: Refill Hogshead, PX Hogshead (6 mo.)

Age: 12 Years (Distilled 7 June 2010, Bottled June 2022)


Nose: Caramel and stewed stone fruits with cherry jam, licorice, and burnt match heads; a panoply of fruity desserts with jujube, ume, perilla, and caramel over occasional hints of butter or leather.

Palate: Medium-bodied, syrupy and waxy, stewed fruits, toffee, birthday cake candles and sugary frosting, more subtle notions of shiso, anise, and black pepper with stewed plums.

Finish: Long and syrupy with stewed fruits and sugary delights.


Score: 6 (79)

Mental Image: Berry Cobbler-Scented Candles

Narrative & Notes: The aroma was fruity and inventing, with stewed peaches, apricots, and plums drifting toward berry jam with a touch of licorice, cinnamon, and butter. Additional depth came through with brunt match sticks and hints of leather as a parade of tangy, almost medicinal jujube, ume, and perilla arrived with more caramel. Medium-bodied, the palate was initially syrupy but quickly turned toward a paraffin or birthday cake candle waxiness.  The mouthfeel was the best part, as the flavors were otherwise standard stewed fruits, toffee, and frosting with more subtle hints of licorice-driven shiso, anise, and tingling black pepper.  The finish was nice and long as the fruits and sugary birthday cake notes continued.

The mouthfeel and finish were beautiful, but the profile featured rather standard sherry-cask-driven flavors. The malt seemed mostly subsumed under the cask, providing that wonderful waxy quality but otherwise drifting off into the netherworld.

Overall, sure to please sherry fans— not bad, but not my style.  It was a touch too sweet to be something I would reach for often.

Image Credit: Whisky Auctioneer

Dailuaine 13 Year (2007), Hidden Spirits Cask DU721

Dailuaine 13 Year (2007), Hidden Spirits Cask DU721

Inchgower 30 Year (1989), Nectar of the Daily Drams

Inchgower 30 Year (1989), Nectar of the Daily Drams